Overcast and Breezy
29FOvercast and BreezyFull Forecast

A clear ... and not so clear value

Mr. Royer (Winergy CEO opinion 29th letter “In support of “RICL”) states wind industry is at a critical crossroad. Any industry that depends on taxpayers’ subsidies on yearly renewal will always be in a crisis.

In 2013, Mr. Royer was one of the 14 wind energy leaders who met with President Obama to request extension of productive tax credit (PTC). A stable industry doesn’t need to beg for taxpayers’ money.

More than $8 billion given the past 21 years amounts to only 3 percent of our nation’s electricity. Now wind is seeking public support and more tax money for interstate transmission projects under the pretense this will improve productivity.

Mr. Royer said Rock Island “Clean” Line (RICL), a 500-mile HVDC line across Iowa and Illinois, is essential to supply the East Coast and Chicago with wind energy. An American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) map shows the best source of wind energy is the Great Lakes and the ocean coast. There is no need to transmit electricity over halfway across the nation.

It is interesting that the four corners western states have not only a supply of wind, but a rich source of coal and natural gas. “Clean” Line has stated a certain percentage would come from wind.

Mr. Royer mentioned if not built, the wind industry would lose “a lot of high-trained and well-paid people.” Who are these people; can’t they be trained in other energy jobs? Well paid, do you start with Mr. Royer?

Mr. Royer claims RICL “will provide energy security, economic prosperity and environmental sustainability.” Wind is only reliable if these high-trained people can make it blow at a steady rate for 24 hours daily. Economic prosperity means the already wealthy investors get richer on the backs of taxpayers and consumers. Environmental sustainability is counting the dead birds and bats under the turbines. RICL claims the increased number of childhood leukemias and adult brain tumors cannot be traced to high DC voltage wires and substations. European studies show elsewise.

Mr. Royer, a supplier of turbine gear boxes, promotes RICL. As a farmer, I promote Del Monte vegetables and the products from our locally grown corn and beans. The difference is my products have a clear value, while RICL project is debatable and fuzzy.

Julene Auchstetter

Peru

Comments

More News

Comments

National Video